Print
Category: ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES
Hits: 900

RUFFLED FEATHERS

Periodical rantings from BSG on the state of the nation!

Are you like me exasperated by recent events of bank bail-outs? What is going on, these irresponsible, greedy, moral-less people got us into this mess in the first place. Does Gordon Brown think they have changed overnight and might be more responsible with hundreds of billions of taxpayers’ money. Even if new regulations are put in place, you can bet they will be light and toothless, politicians here are not about to handicap the City here with regulations if the rest of Europe and the world do not do similar.

The point which seems to grate with me most is the way political leaders talk of returning to normal, of getting back to sustainable growth (a dichotomy of a phrase if ever there was one, how can you have sustainable growth?) of making sure the banking system does not collapse. These dinosaurs are blinkered into only being able to think in one way, same old same old, they do not seem to realise that rampant capitalism will eventually destroy the planet and us along with it. Let me quickly say I am not anti-capitalism, but I do oppose the idea of the sustainability of continuous growth, I oppose rampant consumerism just for the sake of it too (even if I wasn’t a tight Yorkshire man!).

Yes we need to get the economy going again, no one wants a 10 year depression, but giving the banks all our money in my opinion will not work, how much more sense it would have made to give the public money. What if every taxpayer was given say a £20,000 tax break? This would save mortgages, generate trade through people spending, or generate income for the banks by people saving, or buying up cheap shares. People may even start new businesses and I think our political leaders would be well thought of. Yes some banks may collapse, so what, it is their irresponsibility that led them there, do we really want to give the unlimited taxpayers’ money to repeat the process. New banks would rise in their place, perhaps ethical banks that would invest in sustainable industries and not lead us through the same boom and bust cycle of the gambling-minded bankers of before.

Unfortunately most politicians seem unable or unwilling to see the world in any other mode than its status quo. They have reasons for this, and most can be summed up with the words National Security. Their thinking is, as it always was, that to protect our interests we must have strong political clout, and that means a strong economy. To protect our economy, government must be in control of key utilities, such as power generation and travel infrastructure, that we must keep as much arable land in production (or standby set-aside) as practically possible (amazingly Britain is still just about self-sufficient in wheat production!). The government further believes we need to have nuclear technicians available, hence them favouring new nuclear power stations over our massive reserves of British coal; they also toot nuclear as greener, which in terms of carbon dioxide emissions it may be but it is highly polluting in every other way as well as extremely expensive.

Unfortunately, these politicians seem to be fighting the wrong monsters of the id. The spectre of the Cold War has thawed, and while terrorism does pose a real threat it is not a war to be fought in a conventional manner. What politicians seem most unwilling to see, or blind to the fact of, is the elephant in the living room; the threat of human induced global climate change (which is ultimately caused by the number one problem, over population) (see other articles in this section on BSG). Global climate change is a real and present danger now, the last decade was the warmest on record and even cynics now concede that climate change is happening due to man and the effects will be catastrophic (look at wildfires and hurricanes etc). It is now merely the level of catastrophe that is being argued over. Well if you are a conservationist or care about the natural world at all it is already a major worldwide concern; the mass extinction wave has started with amphibians and corals, but is also affecting plants and insects and every other group (see other articles in this section on BSG). But even if you do not care about the environment, it seems pretty clear that climate change is going to make the money spent on bailing out the banks look like peanuts, and if that does not make you concerned then nothing shall.

Environmental Issues

A quick calculation, even on the conservative side will soon illustrate the costs involved. The land loss in Britain could easily be 250,000 ha, not to mention all the houses and other property lost and relocation fees. Where places can or must be saved, sea and freshwater flood defences will reach billions, for London alone. Much arable land will no longer be farmable, and unpredictable weather will cost billions every year. Because the effects will be global, all imports will cost far more, our wildlife will be devastated and tourism will disappear. Fisheries will be devastated too. Disruption to travel and trade as well as energy production will be massive.

But if all this is so, surely the politicians know this, they are not stupid! What is preventing the politicians from acting? Well it is not lack of funding, we have seen how much money can be found when a crisis does arise, if this money had already been spent on climate change prevention, Britain may well have been on target for its emission cuts. Much of the reason again boils down to national security. To keep the country strong we must protect trade and protecting trade means not introducing measures which restrict growth and competition unilaterally. If German, the USA and China are not going to introduce climate change reducing measures then why should we? Sure we will make it law that we will cut our carbon dioxide emission by 80% to please conservationists, but since it is the same government ‘enforcing’ this law as the one that introduced it we do not actually have to act on it. (Just the same thing by the way has been done with our BAP (Biodiversity Action Plan) Farmland Bird species; create targets in law to please conservationists then just do nothing.)

The other major blocker to a sustainable (as in forever usable not forever growing) society is lack of understanding. The current crop of political leaders with rare exceptions are no greener than the ties they wear. They are schooled in traditional politics with traditional problems with tradition solutions, and traditional political parties with traditional ideas and traditional enemies. Thinking outside the box is ok, talking like you mean it might win some votes, but acting on it is political suicide or at least a risk not worth taking for people in the major political parties. They are in short Old School, long in tooth politicians with solutions for the problems today that are the same as the solutions for yesterday, and even then they were ineffective.

What are their issues with greening Britain? Renewable power cannot provide enough power in a sustainable way to replace large-scale power plant production. This is bollocks! Britain is oozing with renewable power, far more than most European countries, from wind and wave, even solar and second-generation biofuel (see Biofuel article on BSG). There is even more renewable power to be had by importing from abroad but the politicians argue about national security and the need for local power production. Much of our oil is already imported from countries with radically different views to ours and if we use nuclear and not coal powered power stations in future we shall still have to import. Power can be imported for instance from solar power stations in the Sahara (see other articles on BSG), unfortunately this proposal is stunted because of the cost of providing high power carrying electric cables all the way across Europe! It seems not to have occurred to these same politicians that it would make far more sense to use the energy to split water (sea-water will do) to produce hydrogen then transport that to Europe. This way stock-piles can be kept in Britain for times of shortage and it can be used for the greening of transport industry. This way any fluctuations in supply can be handled easily with modern technology, by using hydrogen instead of batteries to store up energy in times of excess to be used in times of high demand. Renewable powered water-splitting facilities could produce hydrogen, which can now be easily and safely stored, then when its cloudy, calm and no wind this hydrogen can be used to produce power. It can also form the basis of a new fuel for our transport system.

Solar power cannot be cost effective in Britain by using masses of small-scale units on homes and factories. This also is rubbish, China has already saved the equivalent of 40 large-scale nuclear power plants by the instillation of solar hot water heaters in domestic situations (see Headline News on BSG). Most of the densely populated areas of China receive no more solar energy than Britain. Solar panel are expensive they say. Well of course they are they are not exactly selling many, but with government subsidies they would become mass produced and economies of scale would bring production prices down so subsidies would also come down (do not forget that every means of power production in Britain is heavily subsidised already, especially the nuclear industry). Besides modern advances in solar energy mean this is already a thing of the past, and the panels are nearly 3 times as efficient too (see other articles on BSG about advances in Australia etc). The truth is political leaders want to be in charge of power production for reasons of national security and they also want to be able to tax the energy producers; how complicated would it be to tax individuals for power production, how would the system work? Would you pay more tax for more power production?!

Looking at food production now, it is clear our dead soils can no longer not meet the needs of our wildlife but that they would also not be able to support our crops without massive inputs of fossil fuel based chemicals. These chemicals will become forever more expensive and eventually unattainable on commercial scales as oil supplies dwindle. Permaculture in this country can produce easily 3 times as much food per hectare as conventional intensive arable (though it is not good at producing cereals, nuts have roughly the same energy composition). It also uses no fossil fuels and needs very little labour.

So, what would I like to see and how if at all could it come about? My idea of a sustainable world is not one of sustainable growth with its twisted meaning, but one of sustainable trade, that is trade that does not kill the planet we all depend on in the process. But bringing about change will not be easy, we have all heard the saying that voting for a minority group is a wasted vote (such as voting for the Green Party). But why is it a minority party, millions of people in Britain are concerned about the environment, we have the two biggest conservation NGOs in Europe (National Trust and RSPB) but yet the Green Party has never been voted in unlike in Germany say. This is because of political apathy on the part of Britain’s youth, who do not vote in large numbers and when they do they are not voting in unity instead voting for parties which are too specialized. If the youth could only vote in unity (and it is by and large the youth that are green minded) then we might get somewhere. By far the greenest of the major parties is the Liberal Democrats led by the best leader they have had for a long time Nick Clegg. If we all voted for theLiberal Democrats this would allow other minor green groups to flourish, stimulating green growth everywhere, and come the next election maybe we could vote for the Green Party with confidence.

Author: BSG

www.birdingsiteguide.com